Review Workshop in Hamburg am 03.02.2017

A review workshop with four external experts from science and industry took place on 03.02.2017 as the conclusion of the third work package (WP3). The workshop focused on innovation paths in the German and Indian automotive supply industries, which were identified within the framework of the project. Short profiles of the German and Indian automotive supply industries were presented as well as the results of 32 interviews which had been conducted by the project team with managers from Germany and India.

Overall, the project results received a positive response from the experts. New insights gained as a result of the lively discussion during the workshop are currently being reviewed out and will be included in two working papers on the results of AP3, which will be published here in the near future.

Workshop in Hamburg

(Deutsch) Radiobeitrag: Bitte nicht immer so kompliziert

Sorry, this entry is only available in German. For the sake of viewer convenience, the content is shown below in the alternative language. You may click the link to switch the active language.

Dieser Beitrag des Deutschlandradio Kultur wurde im Zuge des Symposiums über frugale Innovationen verfasst.

Anhand verschiedener bekannter Beispiele aus dem Alltag wird das Phänomen erklärt.

Link zum Beitrag

Project partners present interim results at international conferences

From 19 – 22 June, the project partner TUHH took part in the ISPIM Conference in Porto and presented research results from work packages 1 and 2 in a session entitled “Frugal Innovations – an Innovation Concept Western Firms Cannot Ignore?“.
From 3 – 6 July, both project partners (TUHH and Fraunhofer IMW Leipzig) presented current research results at the RnD Management Conference in Cambridge. In two separate sessions on “Frugal Innovation” organized and led by the TUHH, researchers from Europe and Japan presented and discussed overall 9 papers.
By actively organizing these sessions both conferences could be utilized to engage in a broad discussion with the research community and practitioners and generate new research impulses for the ongoing project apart from disseminating interim results.

Further Information

Frugal Innovation Symposium Video

We are very pleased to publish a short video featuring scenes and interviews from the symposium on frugal innovation in Leipzig on 24 June 2016.

We would like to thank all contributors in the video, Prof. Dr. Cornelius Herstatt (Hamburg University of Technology), Wolfgang Höltgen (team höltgen consulting), Dr. Luise Fischer (Fraunhofer IMW) and Dr. Rajnish Tiwari (Hamburg University of Technology).
The video was produced by Till Feige and Jonas Gerhardt (University of Leipzig).

Report on Workshop in Hamburg in January

First Workshop of the joint project “Potentials of frugal innovation” predicts high relevance of this new innovation paradigm for German industry & society

Participants of the workshop

Participants of the workshop in Hamburg

(Leipzig/Hamburg, April 28, 2016): On 12 January 2016, around 30 stakeholders from industry, academia and politics met in Hamburg to analyse and discuss the relevance of frugal innovations for German companies and society-at-large. Frugal innovations are defined as (technological) solutions, focussed on their core functions robustness, user-friendliness and affordability. This phenomenon has, so far, predominantly been observed in emerging markets. The model of frugal innovations could, however, also hold great potentials for industrialized nations, such as Germany, and other international marketplaces. The importance of frugal innovations is, as evidence shows, expected to increase for the domestic market, too.

The workshop was organised as a part of the joint research project between the Hamburg University of Technology (TUHH) and the Fraunhofer Center for International Management and Knowledge Economy: “Potentials, Challenges and Societal Relevance of Frugal Innovations in the Context of Global Innovation Competition”. The project’s funding is provided by the German Federal Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF) under its ITA programme that seeks to analyse and forecast the potential societal impact of emerging innovations and technologies in the medium-run. The workshop began with a welcome address by Prof. Dr. Cornelius Herstatt (TIM-TUHH), following which Prof. Dr. Tobias Dauth (Fraunhofer Center) introduced the project and the workshop objectives to the participants. During the workshop, the project partners presented their first research results. Dr. Luise Fischer (Fraunhofer Center) presented a discourse analysis in historical perspective, whereas Dr. Rajnish Tiwari (TIM-TUHH) undertook a scientific classification of the term frugal innovation.

Subsequently, three external experts presented their personal and experience-based assessments concerning the relevance of frugal innovations for Germany. The former German ambassador to India Mr. Bernd Mützelburg narrated from his long diplomatic career. He reported that he had seen many German companies facing difficulties and competitive disadvantages in emerging markets due to their technologically highly sophisticated products often regarded as unaffordable by local buyers. Local users also often complained about missing maintenance possibilities for those products. Mr. Mützelburg considered the ability to innovate frugally as key in order to guarantee the international competitiveness of the German industry. This accounted for markets abroad and domestically alike, since the ensuing demographic development and the growing number of senior citizens increased the demand for “simple” solutions.

The Indo-German Chamber of Commerce’s Managing Director in Germany Mr. Dirk Matter furthermore reported about his experience of German companies in India. He said that especially the so-called German “Mittelstand” (composed of SMEs) was far from systematically unlocking the entire market potential in India. Due to products insufficiently adapted for the Indian marketplace, German companies would leave the market to firms from China and other rising nations. This created a major threat for the German export industry.

Wolfgang Höltgen, Managing Director of German-Indian Business Center (GIBC) Hannover and himself an entrepreneur, offered an account of his experience of innovation strategies common amongst the German Mittelstand. Mr. Höltgen spoke of constant innovation and creativity as necessities in order to remain competitive – nationally and internationally. He gave his perception on the particular challenges for the German Mittelstand with regards to investment in innovation and unpredictable forms of innovation. He emphasized the necessity and the benefits of thinking “out of the box”, i.e., to undergo paradigm shifts such as starting to innovate frugally in order to ensure sustainability.

In the further course of the workshop the participants discussed different topics in three focus groups:

  • The relevance of frugal innovation for German companies in the domestic market
  • The relevance of frugal innovation for German companies in global context
  • The socio-political implications of frugal innovation in Germany

Aims of the discussions were to determine, whether frugal innovations will play an important role in the German society and respectively for the German economy in general. The participants of the workshop overwhelmingly agreed that frugal innovations are not a short-lived fad or a fashionable phenomenon, but a long-term development that needs to be taken seriously. The question arose, how the strengths of the research and innovation system in Germany could be used in order to participate in this trend and, where feasible, to shape it. The participants discussed how frugal products and services could be developed and how the concept of frugal innovation could be embedded into the curriculum of degrees, such as engineering courses.

Results of the workshop, including the initial findings of the two project partner institutions, have been published in a working paper entitled “Frugal Innovation in Scholarly and Social Discourse: An Assessment of Trends and Potential Societal Implications”. This working paper has been made available to the interested audience worldwide and can be accessed online free of charge from this website.

Project team and key note speakers at the workshop in Hamburg

The joint research project will be completed by July 2017. Until then the research partners will analyse in depth the relevance of frugal innovation in the German context. A key focus of the research project lies in identifying new (global) innovation trajectories and paths that lead to frugal innovations and in finding out if and in what respects they differ from traditional innovation paths followed by established firms in a mature economy like Germany. For this purpose, it is intended to conduct comparative studies of the automotive component sectors in India and Germany. This study would have a pilot character and is expected to generate new impulses for further, targeted research.

The next public event will be a multi-disciplinary, international scientific symposium on 24 June 2016, taking place at the HHL Leipzig School of Management in the city of Leipzig, for which we have initiated a call for contributions from research. 

Download: Working Paper (PDF. 1 MB)
Download: Text of press release (PDF. 0,3 MB)

Frugal Innovation in Scholarly and Social Discourse

As part of the joint research project between the Center for Frugal Innovation and Fraunhofer Center for International Management and Knowledge Economy a new working paper has been published recently.

The topic of frugal innovation is increasingly gaining relevance in social as well as scholarly discourse. Frugal innovations have been perceived by many to be a phenomenon generally confined to emerging economies where there are large groups of unserved consumers with unmet needs. But there is increasing evidence that this phenomenon is getting relevant also in the industrialized nations potentially affecting the long-term competitiveness of domestic firms not only overseas but also at home. This paper has a three-fold objective: (a)
It seeks to establish the theoretical antecedents of frugal innovation by examining the scholarly discourse; (b) It attempts to generate hypotheses about its long-term relevance by examining historical trends of frugality and their disappearance; (c) It seeks to comprehend the social perception of frugal innovation in the specific German context by assessing the relevant social discourse. Based upon an extensive literature review and some preliminary primary data we propose a new working definition for frugal innovation and hypothesize that frugality was a key social value with positive associations before the era of unprecedented prosperity in the industrialized world, which led to saturated markets and inter alia to feature-driven competition and overconsumption of resources. New ground realities, e.g., economic downturn in the industrialized world and the rapidly rising consumption in the economically developing world, are expected to turn frugality, once again, into an important societal value and frugal innovation into a critical success factor in mid-term future.

Full document: Download (1 MB)

Forthcoming publications will continuously be published on this website. (see list)